Ordinary Time 33
November 15, 2026
Things We Shouldn’t Know
We
usually think that curiosity is a good thing – we should want to know about the
world around us, right? But St. Thomas Aquinas actually says that curiosity can
be a vice – wanting to know things that we don’t need to know. It’s good
to know things about this world, but there are many things we shouldn’t be
curious about because they’re a distraction from our vocation, or because they
risk putting us in a near occasion of sin.
St. Paul
talks about this in today’s second reading. In his day, people were frantically
trying to figure out when Christ was coming again, looking at politics and
natural disasters and societal upheaval to give them signs (does this sound
familiar?). But Paul urges them – focus on what matters, which is your
day-to-day walk with Christ, so that when the day comes, they will be ready.
Curiosity about things we don’t need to know can be a distraction from what we need
to know – and do.
Let’s
talk about four things we don’t need to know.
First,
we don’t need to know about other people’s sins or scandals. As the old
newspaper adage goes, “If it bleeds, it leads” – people are much more fascinated
by evil than by good. I see that in my own teaching and preaching – when I
speak about demons, people sit up and take notice, but when I speak about the
Eucharist, which is the very Body and Blood of God, people yawn as if it were
old news. We love the latest salacious gossip about evil, scandals, and bad
news.
But do
we need to know it all? Do we need to doomscroll and keep ourselves abreast on
the latest dirt? CS Lewis had a great insight here: It is one of the evils
of rapid diffusion of news that the sorrows of all the world come to us every
morning. I think each village was meant to feel pity for its own sick and poor
whom it can help and I doubt if it is the duty of any private person to fix his
mind on ills which he cannot help. (This may even become an escape from the
works of charity we really can do to those we know.) A great many people seem
to think that the mere state of being worried is in itself meritorious. I don’t
think it is. We must, if it so happens, give our lives for others: but even
while we’re doing it, I think we’re meant to enjoy Our Lord and, in Him, enjoy our
friends, our food, our sleep, our jokes, and the birds’ song, and the frosty
sunrise. It’s better not to know the sins, scandals, and bad news of the
world if we can’t help, except maybe to pray for those afflicted.
A second
thing we also shouldn’t need to know is the future. Lord Baden-Powell, selected
for the Boy Scout Motto, the phrase “Be Prepared”. He was asked by a friend,
“Be prepared? For what?” He replied, “Why, for any old thing!” Yes, and we can
be prepared for anything in the future if we have God. The future purposely
remains unknown to us because we are meant to live in childlike trust.
God has
always forbidden people from trying to know the future through occult means:
things like palm readers, psychics, horoscopes, or other forms of divination are
mortal sins and absolutely forbidden by God. Look back at your life – hasn’t
God sustained you thus far, and given you everything you need? If so, why would
you doubt that He will be there in the future, too? So yes, have your five-year
plan and your IRA, but leave the future up to Him.
We also
don’t need to know the ways of God. When bad things happen, it’s natural to
ask, “Why?” Why did my dad die? Why did I lose my job? Why did I get diagnosed
with cancer when I’ve lived a healthy life?
If
anyone had a right to know the answer, it was Job. Job was a man in the Bible
who was a good and righteous man, who had everything bad happen to him. His
children all died in an accident, his flocks were all stolen, and he was afflicted
with a severe disease. His friends came to comfort him and they said, “Well,
you must be a sinner because all this bad stuff happened.” But Job replied,
“No, I’m innocent – so why did God do this to me?” They go back and forth for
about thirty-five chapters in the Bible, until God finally steps in and says,
“Were you there when I laid the foundations of the earth? Were you there when I
created the stars, or the moon? Why do I owe you an explanation?”
The
truth is that we aren’t owed an explanation about how this universe runs. God’s
vision is literally infinitely bigger than ours; if we know He is good and that
He is our Father, then we can trust Him. The movie “Life Is Beautiful”
illustrates this perfectly. A man and his five-year-old son are arrested and
put into a Nazi concentration camp. The father knows he has to protect the
kid’s innocence, so he creates this elaborate game about how the boy is to
survive, telling him that if he follows all the rules, he’ll win a ride in a
tank at the end. The boy is far too young to understand the truth about his
situation, so the father has to hide it from him. We are far too small to
understand the unfolding of God’s Providence, so He hides the ultimate reason,
and our job is to trust Him and surrender to Him.
When I
was in seminary, we came back from Thanksgiving break one year to find that one
of our brother seminarians had died in a car crash. The Rector preached his
funeral Mass, and his message was unforgettable: he said that when we die and
go to Heaven, we will spend the first thousand years saying, “Oh! So that’s why
You allowed that, Lord! So that’s why this or that happened!” We’re seeing only
one small part of the puzzle – and God does not need to reveal the answers to
us now. We just have to play our own role in the unfolding of His plan.
Finally,
we don’t need to know evil. It’s no coincidence that Original Sin occurred upon
eating from the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil – the Hebrew word for
“knowledge” isn’t just head-knowledge, or something you learn from a book. It
means experience. So we are not supposed to experience evil from the
inside-out. There was an old commercial – I forget what it was selling – but it
featured a man in a coffeeshop working on his computer. He looked up and saw a
couple making out – kissing passionately – across the cafĂ©. His face became one
of disgust and horror as he returned to his computer, and the tagline read,
“You can’t unsee things.” It’s true – once innocence is lost, we can’t regain
it. So, we shouldn’t want to experience all the evil that’s out there.
I’ve had
parents tell me, “Oh, it’s fine if my kid gets drunk or sleeps around before
marriage, I want them to have the experience.” Shocking, but that’s absolutely
the attitude of some parents. No, we ought to protect our own innocence and
that of our kids. It’s better not to know sin from the inside out, and be
careful even with learning about sin, because it might make us curious to try
it out!
Curiosity
can be good in some respects – but it can also be a corrupting influence if we
start wondering about things that aren’t ours to know. Let’s instead fill our
minds with Christ and how best to please Him, and leave the rest up to Him!