Homily for
Pentecost Sunday
June 4, 2017
Why Be Catholic?
I trust
Wikipedia far more than I should. I also trust my GPS, my dentist, and my local
newspaper (that last one might be a big mistake). We need to trust things like
that because no one can figure out absolutely everything on their own! I know
nothing about dentistry or auto mechanics – thus, I trust that my dentist and
my mechanic know more than I do about their respective sciences!
As great
as it is to fix a car or show me the best route from Stamford to New Haven, there
are more important matters in life – namely, how to love God well, to follow
Him, and to get to Heaven. So wouldn’t Jesus leave us an authority to guide us
on the most important matters? He did – He left us His Word in the Scriptures,
and He left us His Church to teach His Word without error.
Three
thousand people converted to Christ because of Peter’s preaching on Pentecost –
but it wasn’t his preaching alone that did it. It was the authority behind that teaching – authority because it was filled
with the power of the Holy Spirit. Peter (our first Pope) and the Apostles (our
first Bishops) were given the authority to teach and preach in Christ’s name!
The Gospel features Jesus giving the authority
to forgive sins to His Apostles, through the power of the Spirit. Clearly,
Jesus entrusts His Church with remarkable authority – the authority to preach
and forgive in His name!
Some of
our Protestant brothers and sisters say that the only authority we need is the
Bible. But the Bible itself gives witness that the Church is indispensable –
for example, 1 Timothy 3:15 says that “the pillar and bulwark of the truth is…the
Church!” Besides, there are over 33,000 different Protestant denominations, all
claiming that the Bible is their only authority – yet the Bible is not meant to
splinter us into so many different groups with diverse teachings! Thus, we need
an authentic interpreter of Scripture – one who can tell us how it applies to
modern day.
It’s a
lot like our government. We have our Constitution, which is the foundational
document of our nation. But how does that apply to today? Lots of questions
come up that need answers – so we have the Supreme Court to help us interpret
the Constitution.
But we
have one major difference – we have a promise that the Holy Spirit will never
desert the Church (while our government does not have the same kind of
assurance!). This makes sense – imagine that someone gave you a GPS and said, “Yeah,
this is probably right, but it might make some mistakes.” How likely are you to
trust the GPS – or that fake friend, for that matter? Not likely. So would
Jesus give us His Church if it could be wrong every now and then? What kind of
church would that be? It makes sense, then, that Christ would make sure His
Church would have the gift of the Holy Spirit known as infallibility to make
sure we wouldn’t stray off the path.
Infallibility
means that the Church would never teach an error. Infallibility does not mean
that everyone in the Church is perfect. You may have heard of “The Keepers”
which is a new Netflix documentary that discusses some of the evils committed by a priest
in Baltimore in the 1960s. A friend who watched it posted on social media, “The
Catholic Church is a corrupt organization! I will never set foot in a Catholic
Church again!” I had to respond that while yes, there are many great sinners in
the Church, there are many great saints as well. And only in the Catholic
Church do we find the fullness of grace – through faith, Scripture, and
Sacraments – which can take a sinner and make them a saint! The Church is full
of imperfect people, which is a good thing – because I am an imperfect person!
As the great novelist Walker Percy said to a friend who had converted to
Catholicism, “The Church is a very untidy group you are hooking up with, but it’s
the one thing that will be around until the end!”
This
past week in our middle school lunchtime bible study, we were asking the kids what
they liked about being Catholic. I was expecting something like, “I like our
church building, or the music, or the great coffee and donuts after Mass.” But
in each session, they all said, “I like being Catholic because it is true.” There are a lot of perks to being
Catholic. The saints, the beauty, the tradition…but all of those are not the
main reason. We are Catholic because it is true. It is only here that we
receive Christ’s true Body and Blood in the Eucharist. It is only within the loving
embrace of the Church that we read and interpret Scripture rightly. It is only
here that we encounter Christ in His fullness. St. Ignatius of Antioch said
back in the second century, “Where the bishop is, there is the Church, and
where the Catholic Church is, there is Jesus Christ.”
Why be
Catholic? Because it’s true, and it was established by Jesus Christ with the
authority to lead us to Heaven. That’s good enough for me!