Homily for Ordinary Time 3
January 23, 2022
Historicity of the Gospels
I love
how Luke begins his Gospel because he tells us straight-up that he is writing history,
not a legend. Legends begin with, “Once upon a time…”. But history begins with “In
this specific place, at this specific time…” And Luke makes it clear that he is
not just repeating mythical stories – no, he looked into all of these events himself,
and is writing a historical account of a real man named Jesus.
In 1979, an atheist, Yale-educated
journalist named Lee Strobel was shocked when his wife, an atheist like
himself, converted to Christianity. He wanted to disprove her new faith, so he
set about to investigate the claims of Christianity in the hopes of finding
Jesus to be a myth.
Applying
his journalistic skills to the person of Jesus, he uncovered some startling
facts. He found that every reputable historian agrees that Jesus really existed.
In fact, in the first few centuries after Jesus, there were many pagans – non-Christians
- who wrote about Jesus. Early historians such as Tacitus, Flavius Josephus,
and Pliny the Younger – all of whom wrote in the first two centuries after
Jesus – spoke about him as a really existing person. Even from a secular
standpoint, Jesus actually has more historical evidence than any other ancient person.
Plus,
the Gospels are historical documents themselves. Two of them – Matthew and John
– were both eyewitnesses to the events of Jesus, and wrote their Gospels only
30 years after He lived. We actually have copies of John’s Gospel from about
120AD, so we know that the original manuscripts of the Gospels came from the
first century. The other two Gospels – Mark and Luke – interviewed eyewitnesses
for their material. Mark interviewed St. Peter, and Luke used St. Paul and the
Blessed Mother as his sources.
These
writings agree in the fundamentals. Yes, there are some small discrepancies,
but how many times have you disagreed with your spouse about events that
happened years in the past? The husband says, “Oh, remember that time last year
the Joneses came over and Mary spilled the red wine on her white dress?” And
the wife responds, “It was two years ago, it was the Smiths, and it was
actually a martini.” The small disagreements in the Gospels don’t change the
truth of Jesus – He really lived, preached, did miracles, died on a Cross, and
rose from the dead. After studying all this, the journalist Lee Strobel realized
there was no escaping the truth that Jesus really existed, really claimed to be
God, and really rose from the dead. He converted to Christianity and ended up
becoming a Protestant pastor.
If Jesus
is not just a myth – if He really lived and really died and really rose again –
this has two consequences for us. First, it means we can have a real
relationship with Him. We can’t have a real relationship with Harry Potter or
Luke Skywalker, since they don’t really exist. But I can speak to the Lord –
and He really hears me, because He is real. And…He speaks to us, too!
Nowadays,
people are seeking spirituality in all sorts of places. A month or so ago I met
with a woman who was going through a crisis, and I suggested that she pray
about it. She said, “Yes, I shall consult the energies.” Energies? Since when
do energies hear or answer prayer? She wanted to be “in touch with the universe”
– but the Universe isn’t a person! But Jesus Christ is really alive, a
real person, with whom we can have a real relationship. All of our
spirituality, then, must be based on pursuing a living relationship with Jesus through
daily prayer, Scripture reading, and encountering Him through the Sacraments.
Second,
if Jesus is real and alive, then He truly is the King of the universe – which means
that He has a claim on our lives, and we have to follow Him, live for Him. One
of our church’s greatest saints, St. Augustine, struggled to come to that
understanding. As a kid, Augustine was a wild child. In his autobiography, “Confessions”
(which, interestingly, was the first autobiography in history!), he tells a story
of his teen years, when he and his friends were passing by a pear orchard. The
pears were still small, hard, and unripe, but he decided to steal some and eat
them. Even though they tasted awful, he said that he savored the flavor of his
sin! He loved indulging in sin – he had a child outside of marriage, he ran
away from his super-devout mother St. Monica, and made money and fame the goal
of his life. After many years, though, his sin wore him down and he was sick
and tired of the emptiness of his selfish life. He began to seek truth and
meaning – first looking into a cult of quasi-Christians, before encountering a
holy bishop named St. Ambrose. Ambrose taught Augustine about true
Christianity, and intellectually he became a believer. But it was a struggle to
forsake his sin! One time, he famously prayed, “Lord, grant me holy purity…but
not yet!” He was still a slave to sin, even though he knew that Jesus was truly
alive.
One day
as he was walking through a garden, he was torn up about living this double
life – believing in Jesus but still living for the flesh. He heard a voice off
in a distance singing, “Take up and read!” Looking down, he saw a bible on a bench.
Picking it up, he read St. Paul’s words, “Put on the Lord Jesus Christ and make
no provisions for the desires of the flesh.” He was cut to the heart and
finally able to give up his sin and live for Christ alone. He became a priest,
a bishop, and is one of the greatest saints in our church.
I am so
grateful that St. Luke did what he did – giving us an accurate, historical
account of Jesus Christ. Because if Jesus is real, then I can have a living relationship
with Him, and I must live my life for Him alone. If He really lived and
died and rose again – then this changes everything!